The oldest North American business, the 1670-established Hudson’s Bay Company (HBC), a former colonial power dominating vast Canadian territories, has shut its doors after 355 years. It is not simply a retail collapse, it is the death of an institution that shaped nations.
HBC’s fur monopoly built empires but could not survive the 21st-century retail apocalypse. The shuttering of 80 stores is a reckoning for heritage brands: reinvent or become relics. What drove a company that outlived empires to its downfall? The reasons are a toxic brew of history, hubris, and hysteresis.
From Colonial Powerhouse to Mall Anchor
HBC wasn’t merely a retailer; it was a geopolitical powerhouse. Its 1670 royal charter invested power over 1.5 million square miles of North America, a realm greater than India. By the 19th century, it regulated commerce, charted borders, and dictated Native relations.
But its shift to department stores during the 1900s turned a sovereign power into a mall anchor. This identity crisis, half-historical giant, half-Saks Fifth Avenue manager, left it abandoned between heritage and contemporary relevance. When the internet exploded, HBC’s physical footprint was an albatross, not a legacy.
Private equity’s short-term focus accelerated HBC’s demise; it didn’t have to fail. Asset stripping and leveraged debt after acquisition in 2020 prioritized short-term return over change. Closures facilitated shareholder returns while digital infrastructure subsidized in the rear.
The Toys “R” Us playbook: suck value out, ignore innovation, blow up. HBC’s 355-year test of time is a testament to adaptability, but PE’s “strip and flip” tactic played on its property, not brand value. A company that had survived smallpox epidemics and Métis uprisings could not survive Wall Street greed.
Trade Wars and Cultural Erosion
HBC blamed its demise on the Canada-U.S. trade war and declining foot traffic, but a profound cultural transformation did it in. Younger adults disaffiliated with department stores, and HBC’s Indigenous partnerships, long at its heart for its fur trade, were watered down to tokenized ranges.
Direct-to-consumer brands and fast fashion beat it out over its supply chain, and the company didn’t leverage its history as a differentiator, as heritage brands Burberry did. In a post-truth age, HBC’s authenticity was its blind spot.
The Psychological Cost of Institutional Dissolution
Widespread layoffs due to the closure of HBC will have a ripple effect of trauma: 12,000+ employees face instant job loss, and 2,063 petitioners mourn a cultural icon. Studies show layoffs at iconic institutions aggravate psychological suffering as employees lose not just income but part of their identity.
For Indigenous communities, HBC’s end will serve as a reminder of the colonial expropriation of their lands. In return, a company that made billions taking their land bank account no longer holds any obligation to them. The trickle-down works its way to mall owners and small suppliers, leaving a gap in the retail landscape of Canada.
Cross-examining the Retail Apocalypse Through a Different Lens of a Darwinian Reset
HBC joins Sears and Toys “R” Us in the graveyard, but on a record scale. Over 3,000 North American stores closed in 2025, but HBC’s tale is distinct: its stores were community cornerstones, not throwaway malls. Detractors call it not an apocalypse but Darwinism; eliminating the Métis revolt against the HBC monopoly in the 1850s was an attempt to break it.
Today, it is an attempt to protect it. The irony illustrates how capitalism changes; monopolies don’t have the same bad connotations now as they did then; nostalgia and heritage trumprisk management. Still, somehow, nostalgia cannot repair bad balance sheets.
Does Feeling Nostalgic Help in Today’s Store Closures
A public call to save HBC brought 2,063 signatures, framing the company as a cultural treasure. But can mass sentiment reverse market forces? The Métis rebellion of the 1850s aimed at dismantling the HBC monopoly, while today’s crusade is about preserving the status quo.
Ironically, this also shows the development of capitalism: erstwhile vilified monopolies are now cherished pasts. However, nostalgia can’t turn around a tattered balance sheet by itself. HBC’s outcome is dependent on whether creditors prefer past to future haircuts.
Replacing Land with Data in the Age of New Colonialism
HBC’s 17th-century wealth rested upon real estate ownership; 21st-century giants (Amazon, Meta) profit from information. HBC’s failure to monetize its cache of historical records, a goldmine for AI education, left money on the table.
Imagine HBC converted 355 years of fur trade records, Indigenous treaties, and weather data into capital. Instead, it clung to bricks and mortar, unaware that empires are built today on bytes, not beaver pelts. The lesson: Colonial business models do not apply in digital feudalism.
The Role of Heritage Brands in the Anthropocene Era
HBC’s closing represents a crisis for heritage brands in the climate era. Its fossil-fuelled supply chains and humongous retail presence are at odds with Gen Z’s sustainability expectations. Contrast Patagonia, which made its heritage into environmental activism.
HBC’s striped blankets, once bartered for furs, could have represented circular fashion; instead, they’re heading for the dumpster. To survive the Anthropocene, brands must combine legacies with planetary moralities, which were mocked by HBC leadership until they closed the doors for good.
Understanding the Purpose Behind Corporate Mortality
HBC is not over; it is an alarm bell. Companies, like civilizations, have limits to their lifecycles of 355 years, which is astonishing and time-limited. Second-order consequences run profound: cities lost tax revenue, historians a living chronicle, and Canada a cultural guide.
Yet HBC assets, property, brands, and IP will be pillaged by Private Equity firms, perpetuating the cycle. The takeaway? Corporate immortality requires killing sacred cows: divest in nostalgia, invest in antifragility. In the end, HBC did not succumb to progress; it succumbed to the illusion that history could insulate it from the future.
Discover more DIY hacks and style inspo- Follow us to keep the glow-up coming to your feed!
Love content like this? Tap Follow at the top of the page to stay in the loop with the latest beauty trends, DIY tips, and style inspo. Don’t forget to share your thoughts in the comments — we love hearing from you!