Every day, millions of Americans pour bright orange cereal into bowls, unwrap golden snack cakes, and grab rainbow-colored candy, never realizing they’re eating petroleum-based chemicals banned in much of Europe.
With a market valued at $3.5 billion in 2024, artificial food dyes now face their biggest threat yet. Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s campaign to eliminate synthetic food colors isn’t just a new set of rules, it’s a full-scale challenge to the colorful identity of American processed foods.
What makes this moment so surprising isn’t which brands will fall, but which beloved household names are most at risk. The brands we associate with childhood memories could soon disappear, caught in the crossfire between nostalgia and a sweeping shift in food regulation.
Hostess
Hostess’s Red, White & Blue Twinkies contain five of the most controversial additives flagged by the Environmental Working Group, Red 40, Red 40 Lake, Blue 2 Lake, Blue 1 Lake, and Yellow 5. But Hostess faces a unique problem: the iconic yellow sponge cake is central to its identity.
Without synthetic coloring, Twinkies risk becoming unrecognizable to customers who’ve bought them for nearly a century. Unlike competitors that can quietly reformulate, Hostess must choose between brand survival and compliance, a choice that could cost them everything.
Mars Wrigley
In 2016, Mars pledged to eliminate artificial dyes from M&Ms and Skittles by 2021. That promise quietly disappeared, even as the company continued selling dye-free versions in Europe. While Americans get petroleum-based Red 40, Yellow 5, and Blue 1, Europeans enjoy natural alternatives made from fruit and vegetable extracts. This strategy has exposed a troubling double standard.
With RFK Jr.’s mandate enforcing compliance by 2026, Mars now faces public backlash and possible class-action lawsuits. The brand that asked Americans to “Taste the Rainbow” could soon answer for years of misleading practices and growing consumer distrust.
Kellogg’s
Kellogg’s sells Froot Loops made with natural colors like carrot and watermelon juice in Canada. In the U.S., the same cereal contains artificial dyes and chemical preservatives like BHT. Despite receiving 400,000 protest signatures, only 85% of its U.S. cereals have been reformulated. The remaining 15% includes Kellogg’s top-sellers, where synthetic colors are critical to their vibrant appearance. The irony? Froot Loops owes much of its appeal to a rainbow look that can’t be recreated naturally.
If forced to comply, Kellogg’s risks losing what sets its products apart, making the cereal aisle a lot less colorful, and potentially less profitable.
Ferrara Candy
Ferrara, owned by Ferrero, dominates America’s non-chocolate candy market, but its products are steeped in synthetic dyes. Their Conversation Hearts, for example, contain a cocktail of colors like Red 3, Blue 1 Lake, Yellow 6 Lake, and more, earning them a reputation as the most dye-reliant candies on shelves. These colors aren’t just for fun, they’re foundational.
Unlike chocolate, which relies on natural cocoa hues, hard candies need intense, stable pigments that nature can’t provide at scale. With no viable replacements in sight and no public transition plan, Ferrara may soon face an unthinkable future: mass product extinction.
Mondelez
Mondelez promised to remove artificial colors and flavors from many of its brands by 2020. But Oreo’s seasonal and specialty cookies still rely on synthetic dyes for shelf appeal. The problem? Natural colors often carry unwanted flavors, and taste neutrality is key to cookies like Oreos.
Consumer expectations around visual consistency have put Mondelez in a bind. Any noticeable color shift could weaken trust and damage its billion dollar brand. The company now faces a risky decision: comply with new regulations, or preserve the visual identity that helped Oreo stand out in a crowded market for decades.
General Mills
General Mills successfully reformulated 90% of its cereals using natural colors, but the final 10% reveals the limitations of that shift. Trix, in particular, had to eliminate blue and green pieces because no natural ingredient could match their brightness without affecting taste. This reality exposes a key weakness in the natural color movement, some hues simply can’t be replicated without synthetic help.
For a generation raised on color-saturated breakfast cereals, this marks a major change. General Mills must now grapple with the fact that nature can’t fully deliver on consumer expectations born in a chemically engineered food era.
Campbell’s
Campbell Soup Company aimed to eliminate artificial colors and flavors by 2018, but that goal quietly faded. Products like V8 juices and select soups still use synthetic dyes, largely because consistency is critical for institutional clients like schools and hospitals. Natural color alternatives are vulnerable to seasonal shifts, which complicate production schedules and inventory management.
For large buyers who depend on visual cues for training and portion control, even slight variations are a problem. Campbell’s now faces a dilemma, either comply with upcoming bans or risk breaking contracts worth hundreds of millions. The stakes go far beyond supermarket shelves.
ConAgra
ConAgra’s private label products, including Marie Callender’s pies and Duncan Hines cake mixes, rely on synthetic dyes to stay cost-competitive. But natural alternatives cost 3–5 times more and don’t perform as well. That’s a serious problem in the discount aisle, where price drives everything.
ConAgra calls the expected impact “minimal,” but internally, executives are staring down a crisis. Their low-cost business model depends on the savings from artificial additives. If those vanish, so does their pricing edge. RFK Jr.’s ban could send ConAgra into a financial tailspin, caught between compliance and the rising cost of staying in the game.
Coca-Cola
Coca-Cola’s signature brown hue isn’t natural, it’s the result of a precise chemical process involving caramel coloring, an additive now under regulatory scrutiny due to potential carcinogens like 4-methylimidazole. The FDA already classifies it as artificial, and future bans could shake the entire cola category. The problem is, there’s no natural substitute that delivers the same color or brand recognition.
Without caramel color, cola wouldn’t look, or feel, like cola. For a company that has preserved its formula for over a century, this isn’t just a recipe tweak. It’s a full-blown identity crisis that could affect a pillar of American food exports.
Skittles
Now, let’s take a look at a few favorite products that could be affected by these bans. Skittles are well known for their vibrant rainbow colors, which they achieve with synthetic dyes like Yellow 6, Red 40, Yellow 5, and Blue 1. The ban could possibly force Mars Wrigley to reformulate Skittle with natural colorings, which could change their taste and appearance, or to pull them from shelves.
Cap’n Crunch’s Crunch Berries
Cap’n Crunch’s Crunch Berries feature brightly colored cereal pieces that rely on artificial dyes like Yellow 5 and Yellow 6. With this new ban, Quaker might have to find natural alternatives or risk losing the product’s signature look, which could disappoint fans who love the cereal’s playful, colorful aesthetic.
Gatorade
Some of Gatorade’s most popular flavors, like Cool Blue and Orange, also get their color from synthetic dyes like Blue 1, Red 40, and Yellow 5. If the company were to reformulate to natural colorants, they could change the taste and shelf stability of these drinks, which could put Gatorade at risk of vanishing from store shelves if the ban is enforced.
Pillsbury Funfetti Frostings
Pillsbury’s delicious, creamy frostings with funfetti, especially the Aqua Blue Vanilla and Bold Purple varieties, are favorites because of their eye-catching colors. However, these frostings use Blue 1, Blue 2, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, and Red 40. The ban could force Pillsbury to replicate these colors with natural ingredients, which could change the product’s appeal and texture.
Jell-O
Jell-O has been around for ages and has become a staple at many parties and family gatherings. Unfortunately, flavors like cherry and orange also use synthetic dyes, including Red 40 and Yellow 6. Removing these dyes could force Kraft Heinz to change their recipes, which could affect the iconic look and taste of Jell-O.
Cheetos
Cheetos, especially the Flamin’ Hot and other specialty varieties, are known for their bold orange and red colors, which they get from artificial dyes like Red 40 and Yellow 6. Without these colorants, Cheetos would lose their visual appeal and recognizable branding.
Fruity Pebbles
Fruity Pebbles cereal has been around since the 1970s and is famous for its rainbow colors, which are created with synthetic dyes including Red 40, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, and Blue 1. The ban could force Post Consumer Brands to find natural alternatives, which could change the iconic cereal’s taste and appearance.
Crystal Light
Crystal Light is a low-calorie beverage mix that is famous for its bright, appealing colors, which it gets from synthetic dyes. The ban could force Kraft Heinz to switch to natural colorants, potentially affecting the flavor and visual appeal of Crystal Light.
Kool-Aid
Kool-Aid has been around for decades and is famous for its bold, fun colors and flavors, all achieved through artificial dyes. If the ban is implemented, Kraft Heinz would need to reformulate every flavor, potentially changing the color and flavor.
Haribo
Haribo is known for its delicious gummies. However, the Haribo sold in America is made with synthetic dyes like Yellow 5, Red 40, and Blue 1, unlike the European version, which is made using natural colorings. The ban could force Haribo to change its American recipes, which could change the taste and texture, possibly disappointing fans.
A New Era for Food, or the End of an Era?
RFK Jr.’s push to eliminate synthetic dyes is more than a regulatory shift, it’s a cultural reset for American food. With billions in dye-reliant sales on the line, brands must now face the loss of the chemical foundations that built their identities. The three main artificial dyes, Red 40, Yellow 5, and Yellow 6, account for 90% of usage nationwide. That means nearly every processed food will feel the impact.
The companies that adapt will have to invent new visual identities from scratch. Those that don’t will become relics of an era when bright colors mattered more than clean ingredients.
Discover more DIY hacks and style inspo- Follow us to keep the glow-up coming to your feed!
Love content like this? Tap Follow at the top of the page to stay in the loop with the latest beauty trends, DIY tips, and style inspo. Don’t forget to share your thoughts in the comments — we love hearing from you!